Contraria
Edward C. "Coe" Heller is a Los Angeles-based film producer who believes that if everyone knows something to be true it is probably false. A friend, tired of listening to rants has suggested a blog as a harmless outlet. Coe believes it is vanity, and a chasing after the wind, but is unsure it is harmless.
Sunday, March 13, 2016
Ten years of
scribbling, mostly from the contrarian premise that if everyone knows something
to be true it is probably false. At this
long last I have to admit that there may be one case in which the contrarian
logic has been trumped. Trump.
Reviled by both left and right, a godsend to late night
comics, Donald Trump and his unlikely Presidential campaign have unified all of
Organized America, or America, Inc. like nothing has in many years, but the
unity is an opposition coalition of most unlikely bedfellows. On a recent day the New York Times website
home page had 15 stories, 11 of which were negative writing about Trump. Mitt Romney called him “…a phony, a fraud”. CNN and Fox both cannot stand him and NPR is
apoplectic. The talking heads can’t have
a debate because they all agree that Trump is a menace. Facebook carries the Hitler analogies
probably too far, as the elites on all sides of all issues in every corner of
the nation line up against Donald Trump,
which normally would make me think he must be OK.
As of today Sunday March 13, 2016
Mr. Trump is apparently closing in on the Republican nomination. Maybe on Tuesday Governor Kasich will take
the Ohio primary and maybe Senator Rubio will
take Florida. Maybe, but we can’t see around the corner and
as of today in the absence of a Black Swan Mr. Trump may be the Republican
nominee. From this we learn that he
Republican Party has essentially devolved into something worse than “a party
with bad principles”. “The Liberal
Manifesto”. http://contrariat.blogspot.com/search?q=liberal+manifesto
, and as noted there some ten years ago political parties do come and go, so
maybe it is time.
Which leaves me failing to
understand his success in the voting.
Voters for Trump and Senator Sanders share a common thread – they are
both mad as hell and not going to take it any more. Sanders blames the millionaires and
billionaires. Unlike the Sanders kids
the Trump voters probably admire millionaires and probably aspire to be
them. They may feel that the impediment
to them is from below, from immigrants or minorities – just a different “they”
from the Sanders folks. There is nothing
aspirational and certainly nothing inspirational in the Trump or the Sanders
messages, but at least for the Democrats as of today the center seems to be
holding. For Trump – he apparently won
the vote in Dearborn Michigan, the heart of the Arab community,
so I will admit to knowing nothing.
I have tried to play my role to find
some reason why the Contrarian principle should not apply to Trump. I really don’t care if there is a wall with Mexico. After all, we do have immigration laws and if
replacing the current fence with a wall is necessary, well, OK. But on the other hand, “They’re rapists” was
wrong, wrong and unjustifiable. I am
not a fan of Syrian immigration, but banning Muslim immigrants just isn’t
us. Labeling some “them” as the enemy
won’t withstand taking it down to a human level. “Luke and the Mortgage Crisis”.
http://contrariat.blogspot.com/2009_01_01_archive.html
I could justify campaign vulgarity on the grounds that
Senator Rubio started it, but we have to have some standards for the Leader of
the Free World. I would like to say
that fears are overblown, that he has no history of fascism and that he is a
businessman who makes deals, but the campaign gives us no evidence of any of
that.
Ultimately I need to surrender and recognize that some days the
indefensible cannot be defended. On Donald Trump’s campaign my best efforts to
be a contrarian have been Trumped.
Sunday, December 04, 2016
The Empire Strikes Back
And now, Our Empire, America, Inc. has been Trumped. In a confounding of all order Donald Trump
has been elected President of the United States, and We of the bi-coastal elite
who know so much better and more than the rednecks in flyover country have been
kicked to the curb.
I predict that nothing good is going to come from the Trump presidency, but the issue for most of us is what to think
now and how to react.
The campaign was endless and daily plumbed the depths of depravity in
every way. Rubio’s crude sexual slander (my
goodness!) drew Trump’s response (why?) that he is just fine in that department
(good Lord!?!). The sole comfort was
that We knew how it would end…Secretary Clinton would win someplace between
comfortably and by a landslide. We knew
it because it had to be.
But sometimes life imitates art, from History of the World Part I:
Count De Monet - Sir, the peasants
are revolting!
King Louis - You said it. They stink on ice.
What Our candidate actually said on Our behalf was:
“You could put half of Trump's supporters
into what I call the basket of deplorables. Right? The racist, sexist,
homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic -- you name it. And unfortunately there
are people like that. And he has lifted them up…He tweets and retweets their
offensive hateful mean-spirited rhetoric. Now, some of those folks -- they are
irredeemable, but thankfully they are not America.”
Now, the thing about that statement is that although We actually believe
it, to call half of the population who voted for Trump “deplorables” and “irredeemable”
a few weeks before the election is pretty poor judgment for a candidate who
says she wants to be a President of all Americans. It was not an attack on Trump – it was an
attack on all of white male, heterosexual middle America
and on people participating in the political process. It got them to put down their beer and
Doritos and go vote.
And we, the bi-coastal Empire of America, Inc. of media, arts, hedge fund
managers, professionals and tenured academics, those who give lip service to
democracy but really believe in a Platonic intellectual oligarchy sat in
stunned incredulity as the Deplorables’ votes were counted and a sea of red
engulfed our dumbfounded sputtering fellow travelers on TV.
We are in varying stages of grief.
President Obama correctly noted that on the day after the election the
sun duly arose in the east at the appointed hour, but we have one friend who
announced that she is withdrawing from Facebook and from society in general to
nurse her wounds on a mountaintop. The
administration in formation is not what we expected or would choose, but time
will tell if it is Apocalyptic.
The Empire however, does not miss a beat, and We will neither acknowledge
defeat nor give Ourselves a moment of uncertainty. As I write these words the Grey Lady’s online
front page screen says (i) Trump has been sued in his businesses, (ii) Trump is
dividing Republicans on who should be Secretary of State, (iii) Trump built a
wall at his golf course in Scotland, (iv) Trump will unravel climate agreements,
(v) Florida citizens will lose health care, (vi) Trump manipulated fake news
from Russia, and all that is what is “above the fold”. The drumbeat of self-delusion goes on. NPR reports that school districts are
deploying grief counselors to treat the children for electoral post-traumatic
stress, and yesterday a talking head was telling Us how to deal with Trump
supporters who might “gloat” at the table because they feel that stupid people
were not given enough respect.
Seriously. The Empire Strikes
Back.
The rabbi, like President Obama took a more measured approach. The rabbi said first that maybe, just maybe
We don’t really know as much as We think, that some degree of humility might be
in order. I thought that was a vicious
attack at the belly of the beast. Then
he said that perhaps We should get out of our silos, as though the thought of
taking a deplorable or an irredeemable to lunch could be a whole new
thing. The Liberal Manifesto is 10
years old. http://contrariat.blogspot.com/search?q=liberal+Manifesto. On the whole it has aged well.
Wednesday, September 13, 2006
The Liberal Manifesto Part 3
The Liberal Manifesto Part 3. We are not Democrats
We are not Democrats because:
1. We reject the identity politics of the Democratic party which divides us by race, gender, sexual orientation or other identity issues. We are better people as Americans than as hyphenated Americans, and we reject the quotas and pandering which have become the daily fare of the Democrats.
2. We reject the moral relativism of Democrats who proclaim that all values are of equal value and who therefore stand for nothing.
3. We take pride in our successes and do not gloat at our failures. While Democrats seek to fix the blame, Liberals seek to fix the problem.
4. We oppose judicial rejection of legislative prerogative. We understand the difference between constitutional rights and judicial preferences, and fear the day when radically conservative justices may take the same liberties as radical Democratic judges have in the most recent past.
5. We reject "political correctness", speech codes, thought control and censorship.
6. We believe that rights cannot be separated from responsibilities. The proliferation of rights separated from responsibilities of citizenship is not to the benefit of our country.
We are not Democrats because:
1. We reject the identity politics of the Democratic party which divides us by race, gender, sexual orientation or other identity issues. We are better people as Americans than as hyphenated Americans, and we reject the quotas and pandering which have become the daily fare of the Democrats.
2. We reject the moral relativism of Democrats who proclaim that all values are of equal value and who therefore stand for nothing.
3. We take pride in our successes and do not gloat at our failures. While Democrats seek to fix the blame, Liberals seek to fix the problem.
4. We oppose judicial rejection of legislative prerogative. We understand the difference between constitutional rights and judicial preferences, and fear the day when radically conservative justices may take the same liberties as radical Democratic judges have in the most recent past.
5. We reject "political correctness", speech codes, thought control and censorship.
6. We believe that rights cannot be separated from responsibilities. The proliferation of rights separated from responsibilities of citizenship is not to the benefit of our country.
The Liberal Manifesto - Part 2
The Liberal Manifesto Part 2 : We are not Republicans
We are not Republicans because:
1. We believe that the government has an important and positive role to play in improving the lives of its citizens. The government needs to have pro-active concern for the poor, the disabled, the elderly and allocate the resources to address those concerns.
2. We believe that the market economy will not adequately deal with long term concerns such as health care, the environment or energy supplies.
3. We support a right of women to choose to terminate many unwanted pregnancies. We do not support efforts to artificially define a moment of the start of life or to interfere with medical research. In 2006 the President is wrong to oppose stem cell research. We believe that whatever wrong he may believe is occasioned by such research, the wrong of opposing the research is greater.
4. We believe that, except in extraordinary circumstances the federal budget should be balanced. Wars should be paid for from current taxes to the extent possible. We do not agree with current Republican aversion to paying for the Iraq war or the consequences of blind reduction in taxes.
5. We believe in a strong national defense for protecting our nation and our allies. We oppose the hubris of making the world conform to our standards.
6. We do not imagine the world to be in social stasis, but we welcome evolution of society and the creation of new values. We are willing to change our minds.
We are not Republicans because:
1. We believe that the government has an important and positive role to play in improving the lives of its citizens. The government needs to have pro-active concern for the poor, the disabled, the elderly and allocate the resources to address those concerns.
2. We believe that the market economy will not adequately deal with long term concerns such as health care, the environment or energy supplies.
3. We support a right of women to choose to terminate many unwanted pregnancies. We do not support efforts to artificially define a moment of the start of life or to interfere with medical research. In 2006 the President is wrong to oppose stem cell research. We believe that whatever wrong he may believe is occasioned by such research, the wrong of opposing the research is greater.
4. We believe that, except in extraordinary circumstances the federal budget should be balanced. Wars should be paid for from current taxes to the extent possible. We do not agree with current Republican aversion to paying for the Iraq war or the consequences of blind reduction in taxes.
5. We believe in a strong national defense for protecting our nation and our allies. We oppose the hubris of making the world conform to our standards.
6. We do not imagine the world to be in social stasis, but we welcome evolution of society and the creation of new values. We are willing to change our minds.
Monday, October 09, 2006
The Euston Manifesto - Ain't Life a Bitch
I published a three part piece, "The Liberal Manifesto" on September 13, 2006. I had been working on it for a while, one part principles, one part distinguishing from the Right and one part distinguishing from the Left. Balanced, I thought. And although I am certain that portions of the Manifesto will not age well I tried to leave a little wiggle room to change my mind later. A month later it looks...pretty much the same.
Now I find The Euston Manifesto, published in America on September 12, 2006 at www.eustonmanifesto.org. The day before? The day before. And, unless I dreadfully misread it, expressing better than my tentative effort, more than my jumbled thoughts in a cogent, succinct and compelling narrative. Good for Professor Herf et als. I should become a signatory, but will count to 10 first. Probably more later, perhaps a piece on being a day late and a dollar short. Ain’t life a bitch?
Now I find The Euston Manifesto, published in America on September 12, 2006 at www.eustonmanifesto.org. The day before? The day before. And, unless I dreadfully misread it, expressing better than my tentative effort, more than my jumbled thoughts in a cogent, succinct and compelling narrative. Good for Professor Herf et als. I should become a signatory, but will count to 10 first. Probably more later, perhaps a piece on being a day late and a dollar short. Ain’t life a bitch?
Saturday, December 30, 2017
Free at Last
Free at
last. Free at last. Thank God almighty I am free at last.
I have left the Democratic Party,
resigned from the City Committee and am officially “unenrolled”. The weight is off my shoulders, so at least I
do not feel responsible for what My Former Party does.
11 years ago I observed in these
pages that we “…have a choice between two parties, one of which has bad
principles and one of which has no principles at all.” http://contrariat.blogspot.com/search?q=liberal+manifesto
For many years I have identified as a Democrat both because I am a
card-carrying member of the bi-coastal elite and because a party with no
principles at least has the option of getting some things right if only by
accident.
Lately, however I have determined that MFP actually does have principles,
and even if we cannot be Republicans being in MFP is untenable.
The President has nominated Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court. If I were President I would not have
nominated him, but by any measure he is qualified to serve as a Justice. 45 Senators from MFP voted against him, out
of political spite, only the latest episode of a trend MFP started in 1988 with
the Bork nomination, a trend which has done infinite damage to our
institutions.
MFP has come out against “free speech” – the kind with “air quotes”
quotation marks in a pandering to African-Americans who may be too fragile to
engage in discussions. Our local
candidate for Mayor used the air quotes in a video message. I cannot agree with that and recall that in
1967 as a ROTC midshipman I was investigated by the Office of Naval
Intelligence for insisting that the SDS had the right to live in peace on
campus. Free speech does not get air
quotes.
Professor Mark Lilla of Columbia
has written “The Once and Future Liberal” in which he argues that MFP has
followed the path of identity politics down a dead end. The Democrats have taken the “we” out of our
society and substituted a narrow vision of “me” with an identity label. He writes (p 102)
At a time when we liberals need to convince
people that they share a common destiny our rhetoric encourages self righteous
narcissism. We have no political vision,
and we are thinking and speaking and acting in ways guaranteed to prevent one
from emerging.
Lilla notes that the anti-Trump
movement is wholly negative, offering nothing to anyone other than anger, and
when MFP allocates convention seats by identity quotas the participants are so
focused on themselves that they acquire distain for politics because it means
engaging with people unlike themselves.
This in turn explains why MFP believes that the judges should make the
laws, so the politicians do not need to be responsible for anything. Lilla proposes a prescription for righting
the Party’s ship, and he suggests that MFP should back off identity politics
and focus on “we”, and what we can do for our country. Ain’t happening. MFP will double down on the bad stuff.
If I needed a final straw the dismissal of Senator Al Franken about sums
it up. Accused of what is now but at the
time was probably not “sexual assault” he was tried, convicted, sentenced and
executed by his Senate colleagues of MFP without either fact-finding or process
and perhaps most importantly without a shred of decency or
proportionality.
The Republicans are most assuredly jerks, but if MFP is different it is
only in degree and not in kind. To quote
Ronald Reagan, – “I did not leave the Democratic Party, the Democratic Party
left me”.
Free at last.
Wednesday, September 13, 2006
The Liberal Manifesto- Part 1
There is a specter haunting America. The specter of diffidence.
I observe the political spectrum and have a choice between two parties, one of which has bad principles and one of which has no principles at all. I observe that across time several political parties in America have outlived their usefulness and withered away. The Federalists, the first Democrats, the Whigs. In Israel the two parties which founded the country, Labor and Likud have played to their narrower and narrower party bases leaving the majority with no home, and a most unlikely protagonist, Ariel Sharon, broke the molds, and prior to his stroke formed a new party of the Center. At this writing it appears that the party will survive Sharon’s departure from the scene.
Do we not have the same splintering in America? Certainly writers have noted that the party rules of both parties have tilted the nomination processes to the radical right for the Republicans and the radical left for the Democrats. There are no more "Rockefeller Republicans", and Joe Lieberman is out as a Democrat in favor of Ned Lamont who stands on primary night with Al Sharpton. Is there nothing between Dennis Hastert and Al Sharpton? How about a party for the 80% of Americans who are neither Hastert nor Sharpton?
What would such a party look like in America? First, we will be called the Liberals. Some people think that’s a bad thing, but it is a badge which summons our best spirit. We will probably sound a little like "neo-liberals", but that is mud-slinging. We are not Democrats and we are not Republicans. Some may be "Reagan Democrats" and some may have held their noses and voted for Kerry.
We have certain principles which we deem to be important.
1. We are Americans. We are proud of our past and optimistic about our future.
2. We have faith in our political system of democratically elected representatives. We have tolerance for decisions freely made, and will work to change decisions with which we disagree.
3. We believe in a social compact in which Americans have shared rights, but also shared responsibilities.
4. We believe that political freedom is intrinsically tied to economic freedom and cultural freedom.
5. We believe peace is our first and best foreign policy. We are a nation which can lead the world best by example. We will maintain the world’s most powerful military as an instrument of peace. We have defeated fascism and communism, and the energy and freedom of our people will defeat any future threat.
6. We believe in a positive domestic policy of compassion, planning, management and tax equity, balancing the budget and providing sufficient revenue to provide for national needs.
I observe the political spectrum and have a choice between two parties, one of which has bad principles and one of which has no principles at all. I observe that across time several political parties in America have outlived their usefulness and withered away. The Federalists, the first Democrats, the Whigs. In Israel the two parties which founded the country, Labor and Likud have played to their narrower and narrower party bases leaving the majority with no home, and a most unlikely protagonist, Ariel Sharon, broke the molds, and prior to his stroke formed a new party of the Center. At this writing it appears that the party will survive Sharon’s departure from the scene.
Do we not have the same splintering in America? Certainly writers have noted that the party rules of both parties have tilted the nomination processes to the radical right for the Republicans and the radical left for the Democrats. There are no more "Rockefeller Republicans", and Joe Lieberman is out as a Democrat in favor of Ned Lamont who stands on primary night with Al Sharpton. Is there nothing between Dennis Hastert and Al Sharpton? How about a party for the 80% of Americans who are neither Hastert nor Sharpton?
What would such a party look like in America? First, we will be called the Liberals. Some people think that’s a bad thing, but it is a badge which summons our best spirit. We will probably sound a little like "neo-liberals", but that is mud-slinging. We are not Democrats and we are not Republicans. Some may be "Reagan Democrats" and some may have held their noses and voted for Kerry.
We have certain principles which we deem to be important.
1. We are Americans. We are proud of our past and optimistic about our future.
2. We have faith in our political system of democratically elected representatives. We have tolerance for decisions freely made, and will work to change decisions with which we disagree.
3. We believe in a social compact in which Americans have shared rights, but also shared responsibilities.
4. We believe that political freedom is intrinsically tied to economic freedom and cultural freedom.
5. We believe peace is our first and best foreign policy. We are a nation which can lead the world best by example. We will maintain the world’s most powerful military as an instrument of peace. We have defeated fascism and communism, and the energy and freedom of our people will defeat any future threat.
6. We believe in a positive domestic policy of compassion, planning, management and tax equity, balancing the budget and providing sufficient revenue to provide for national needs.

