Contraria

Edward C. "Coe" Heller is a Los Angeles-based film producer who believes that if everyone knows something to be true it is probably false. A friend, tired of listening to rants has suggested a blog as a harmless outlet. Coe believes it is vanity, and a chasing after the wind, but is unsure it is harmless.

Monday, February 06, 2006

On Bullshit

Princeton professor Harry G. Frankfurt has published a pamphlet entitled On Bullshit (Princeton University Press, 2005), 65 small pages of large type which ought not require additional condensation.

Frankfurt starts, "One of the most salient features of our culture is that there is so much bullshit....But we tend to take the situation for granted...In consequence we have no clear understanding of what bullshit is...".

Other words have similar or parallel import, such as "humbug" or "claptrap", but the author finds that bullshit has particular traits and differences from showmanship or misrepresentations or similar concepts. Somehow we know that bullshit is a particular type of misrepresentation.

Frankfurt makes the most specific comparison and contrast between bullshit and lying. In lying the untruth is the goal. The liar wants the listener to think true something which is not true for the purpose of gaining whatever the liar seeks. Bullshit, on the other hand is essentially the indifference to truth. Bullshit does not have to be false, but the bullshit artist speaks without the underlying concern as to whether it is true or false, because that is not his goal. His goal is something else, to project an image, to get the girl, or to get elected, so the truth or falsehood of what is said is immaterial, only the achieving of some other goal. The liar lies to convince the listener of an inaccurate fact. The bluster is indifferent to the truth because he is unconcerned with the facts. Both an honest person and a liar have concern with the truth. A bulshitter is indifferent to the truth.

The best place to test Frankfurt’s theory, of course is C-SPAN. No shortage of bullshit there.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Si



 
       We are returned from Monterrey, Mexico after the marriage of Number One Son’s sister in law.   We busied ourselves with some sightseeing before the typical lavish Mexican wedding in a gorgeous church with a rollicking all-night party.  At the last wedding Trophy Wife and I gave up on staying up with the Mexicans, and we took our leave on the early side…for them.
       The cultural gaps are hard to fathom, but I have focused on a new appreciation of the word “si”.  I have always thought that it is two words, “yes” and “if”, and literal translations will use them as such.  However, I now believe that it is actually one and the same word – as though “yes” is a conditional, and perhaps it is best translated in both senses as “maybe”.  To Americans there is a simple binary veracity – “yes”, twinned with “no”.   To Mexicans, however, it may be impolite or unhelpful to say “no”,  or there may be uncertainty or conditionality, or it may have a different linguistic framework, so they will answer “si” when we might expect “no” or “I don’t know”.
      We took a taxi to the wedding, showed the taxi driver the address of the church on the invitation – about 5 blocks from the hotel.  Does he know it?  “Si”.  He had no idea, took us 2 or 3 miles out of the way, and eventually I had to find the church for him. 
       We asked the hotel if they could send a taxi to the reception venue to pick us up later in the evening.  “Si”.  As a back-up we asked the maitre d’ if he could get us a taxi back to the hotel.  “Si”.  1:30 A.M., no taxis available from either source and a not-so pleasant and not much recommended walk through downtown Monterrey to the hotel. 
       I do not think anyone was lying, as they did not know there would be no taxis,  nor do I think it was Bullshit http://contrariat.blogspot.com/search?q=Bullshit, as they were not indifferent to the truth, but genuinely hoped there might be a taxi.  It is just that “si” doesn’t mean what I think it means.  In Mexico it is some kind of affirmative conditional meaning a combination of what we think of as “yes” and “if”.
     We should not have walked to the hotel.  We should not have been so concerned about time or “si”, and we should have been more Mexican and waited for someone to leave the wedding who would have been happy to drive us back. 
      

Sunday, August 04, 2013

John Died




          My friend John died on Friday.  He beat the cancer and the heart attack, but the ALS was inexorable and unrelenting .  Some months ago I asked if he was going to get an eye-controlled computer, and he told me "I'm not going to be that guy", his way of saying he would die when he could no longer function.  When the pneumonia came, in the hospital he said in his own way, "I'm all done", meaning that he would not take the ventilator.

            John said a lot of things like that.  He spoke in simple, direct statements, unadorned but full of meaning, and he was incapable of any form of bullshit.   In some ways John was a series of contrasts.  He had a round red face from a light complexion that might have made him look angry, but he was a pussycat.  He was a soft spoken and always-polite general contractor.  He was successful in his business but always drove a Ford, particularly to job sites so he wouldn't stand out.  The banker noted that his company overhead is unusually high, which only means that John kept a few of "the guys" on the payroll doing odd jobs.  John chaired the Boys Club annual dinner and raised all the money for the event and then skipped the dinner because he didn't like that sort of thing and might have been asked to speak in public.  He was well known in his community, in business and had close friends, but he was painfully shy with other people.  We saw a door mat we wanted to get for John - where most of them say "Welcome"  this one said "Go Away".  

            If it is a possible concept, John lived the good life in an unassuming way.  He disliked suits and always looked uncomfortable when someone made him wear one, so at most business meetings he was in khakis and a polo shirt, making him look casual, but they were both from Brooks.  His house was on the water, but in a town off the beaten path, where it is magnificent but does not stand out.  The boat he kept at the dock was rigged for fishing which he enjoyed.

            People sought out John because he did the simple things.  He said "yes" and "no", and when he bought something he made a deal and wrote a check.  He landed a big corporate customer that got his construction company to another level and worked for most of  his clients repeatedly for decades.  Telling the truth cost him bidding opportunities, but it won him more than it lost.  In a down time in the 90's he designed and built our beach house which I love and in which I now sit, me whining for 20 years that he overcharged me and him complaining that I didn't ask for any change orders.       

            John and I met in in business in 1988  and we bonded in an overnight drive from Jackson Mississippi to Mobile with an after-midnight stop for grits off Route 98 in Hattiesburg.  It was quite a night. John has appeared in these pages before, mostly as a traveling companion in Argentina and on Route 66.   Trophy Wife counted that we have taken 7 trips over 15 years with John and Maureen.  I'm not so easy to spend that much time with, a tribute to John's patience, flexibility and willingness to stay at the Hilton Gardens.

             In fact, it is amazing we were friends at all, but we filled some need in each other.  John was born in Sri Lanka and grew up in the 50's and 60's in India, the child of an oil expatriate.  He didn't know about the TV shows we grew up with or the music of the 60's.  He went to a Catholic community college, knew how to use tools, put my worm on and took my fish off the hook when we went on his boat (and filleted, wrapped and packed the bluefish in ice).  In all those things, in an entire life of background John was on paper the opposite of a Jewish Ivy League contrarian.

            And yet we could sit and gab for hours like teenage girls.   About business, about family, about our contrasting backgrounds, about traveling or food, about deals we had done, missions accomplished, disasters avoided.  On the boat, out for dinner or driving a thousand miles on Route 66, being with John was just plain comfortable.    When I went to the hospital to say goodbye – actually what I said in our style was “Do the best you can” -  he wouldn't talk about himself beyond "I'm all done".  He asked about Shorty, and his last words to me were "You have to go home" - a joke between us that in the middle of a deal I would abruptly end phone calls at 6:15 because I go home for dinner at 6:30.  I told John that I had planned on seeing the rest of the world with him over the next decades, and that maybe I'll spend the time with Shorty.  I touched his head, held his hand and went home for dinner.

           

Monday, August 08, 2011

Downgraded

We been downgraded.  Totally dissed.

Standard & Poors has downgraded US government debt,  and the Dow fell over 1000 points, about 9% in the past three days.  Early reports say that most of the stock sellers were in a flight to safety – to recently downgraded US government debt now with rates falling due to increased demand.   Which I suppose makes some kind of perverse sense, much like the debate which preceded it.
           The S&P action follows our national humiliation as the President and Congress tried to raise the debt ceiling,  a crisis manufactured by Republicans to assure that any economic train wreck occurred while President Obama is in office. http://contrariat.blogspot.com/2010/11/train-wreck-ahead.html.  The failure of Congress to address the nation’s debt and revenue issues was stunning and craven, and I happened to have observed the worst of it through the eyes of the world while visiting #2 Son in England.  They think we are nuts, and they are right.
           No one I know thinks much other than that there is a serious problem, and that the necessary steps to deal with it include some debatable mix of spending cuts and  revenue increases, something like what President Obama almost worked out with Speaker Boehner.  Contraria believes, however that this fight was twice lost by the Democrats.  First, in December 2010 with majorities in both houses and the 2001 tax cuts about to expire the Democrat majorities caved to the Republicans in extending the tax cuts.  The President after running and railing against the tax cuts sugar-coated his defeat by announcing that the extensions were a good way to stimulate the economy.  Bullshit, but it proved that the President could be bullied by the Republicans and that the Democrats were as usual wholly unprincipled.
           Worse was the scene after the President and the Speaker reached most of an agreement when Senator Reid announced a Democratic plan with no new revenues.  When the President stood alone against both parties in Congress Boehner could not support new revenue when Reid did not, so the negotiations collapsed.
           The Congress manufactured a crisis and failed to deal with it.
           We deserve to be downgraded, but no good will come from this.